When you start the exciting journey of buying a home in Austin, square footage often tops the list of criteria. It seems like a simple, concrete number to guide your search. You might recall the size of previous homes, calculate a minimum you think you need, and set your search filters accordingly.
While this approach feels logical, it’s not always the most effective way to find your next home. In fact, fixating on square footage can sometimes cause you to overlook a property that would be a perfect fit for your lifestyle. As experienced buyer’s agents, we often advise our clients to look beyond this single metric. Here’s a detailed look at why you should consider ignoring square footage and what to focus on instead.
The Measurement Maze: Why Square Footage Isn’t Standardized
One of the biggest issues with relying on square footage is that there is no universal standard for measuring it. The number you see on a listing can be calculated in several different ways, and each method can produce a different result. This lack of consistency makes it an unreliable benchmark for comparison.
Let’s break down the common sources of square footage data and their potential discrepancies:
- Appraisers: Professional appraisers typically measure the exterior of the home to determine the gross living area (GLA). However, their standards can vary. Some might only include finished, walkable spaces with adequate ceiling height, while others might have different criteria. They usually exclude areas like garages, unfinished basements, or three-season porches.
- County Tax Records: The local tax authority, like the Travis Central Appraisal District (TCAD), has its own set of records. This data is often based on the original building permits. If a previous owner completed an unpermitted addition or renovation, the tax records may not reflect the home’s current size. This is a common occurrence, leading to significant inaccuracies.
- Homeowners and Listing Agents: A seller might provide their own measurement, which could include spaces that an appraiser would exclude, such as a converted garage, a finished attic with low ceilings, or even a covered patio. While they might see these as usable living spaces, they don’t always align with official measurement standards. Listing agents enter the square footage into the Multiple Listing Service (MLS), often using the most readily available number, which could be from any of these sources.
Because the MLS only has one field for square footage, you rarely know the origin of the number. Is it from the detail-oriented appraiser, the outdated tax record, or the optimistic seller? This ambiguity means you could be comparing apples to oranges.
A Matter of Opinion, Not Fact
Given the various measurement methods, it’s more accurate to think of square footage as an opinion rather than an exact science. You could ask four different people—an appraiser, a tax assessor, the homeowner, and a real estate agent—to measure the same house and receive four different answers.
When a metric can vary so much, using it as a strict, non-negotiable requirement for your home search is problematic. It can lead you to unfairly dismiss homes that are listed with a slightly lower square footage number but might feel much larger in person.
Layout Trumps Size: How a Home “Lives”
Have you ever walked into a large house that felt surprisingly cramped or a smaller home that felt spacious and open? This is a perfect illustration of why the layout, or floor plan, is far more important than the raw square footage number. How a home is designed and how its space is utilized determines how it “lives.”
We’ve seen 3,000-square-foot homes with poorly designed layouts—long, narrow hallways, oddly shaped rooms, or wasted space in areas you’d never use—that feel more like 2,000 square feet. Conversely, we’ve toured beautifully designed 1,500-square-foot homes with open-concept layouts, smart storage solutions, and no wasted space that feel as functional and spacious as a 2,000-square-foot home.
The value of square footage is entirely subjective and depends on your personal lifestyle. If a home’s square footage is concentrated in areas you don’t value, it offers you no benefit.
- For the Entertainer: A large, open kitchen and living area might be the top priority.
- For the Remote Worker: A dedicated office space, even if it’s small, is more valuable than a sprawling formal dining room that will never be used.
- For the Growing Family: The number of bedrooms and the flow between them might be more critical than the total square footage.
Your personal needs and how you envision living in a space are what truly matter. A number on a page can’t capture that.
A Better Way to Search: Focus on What Really Counts
Instead of getting hung up on square footage, we encourage buyers to concentrate on more practical and telling features. Focusing on these elements will give you a much better indication of whether a home will meet your needs.
1. The Floor Plan
Examine the layout of the home. Does it flow in a way that makes sense for your family? Consider:
- Open vs. Traditional: Do you prefer an open-concept living area, or do you like the separation of a more traditional layout?
- Bedroom Placement: If you have young children, you might want the bedrooms clustered together. If you have teenagers or frequent guests, a split floor plan with the primary suite separated from other bedrooms might be ideal.
- Functionality: Is there a mudroom, a dedicated laundry room, or enough storage? Think about your daily routines and whether the layout supports them.
2. Number of Bedrooms and Bathrooms
This is a straightforward and crucial metric. Ensure the home has the right number of bedrooms and bathrooms to accommodate your family and guests comfortably. If you need a home office, a guest room, and a playroom, a four-bedroom home might be a better fit than a three-bedroom, regardless of the total square footage.
3. Room Dimensions and Usability
Instead of the total size, think about the usability of individual rooms. A home might have a huge primary bedroom but tiny secondary bedrooms. Or perhaps the living room is large, but its shape makes furniture placement awkward. Pay attention to the dimensions and layout of the rooms that are most important to you.
When Is Square Footage Actually Helpful?
Of course, square footage isn’t completely useless. It can be a helpful tool for setting broad search parameters and ruling out homes that are clearly not a fit. For instance, if you know you need a large home for your family of six, you can safely eliminate 1,200-square-foot bungalows from your search.
The key is to use it as a general guideline, not a rigid rule. It helps you get into the right ballpark, but it shouldn’t prevent you from exploring homes that are slightly outside your initial range.
Our Pro Tip: Give Yourself a Square Footage Buffer
If you’ve determined that 2,000 square feet is the absolute minimum you can live in, we recommend setting your search criteria a bit lower—perhaps to 1,800 or 1,900 square feet.
This doesn’t mean you have to buy a smaller home if it doesn’t suit your needs. It simply ensures you are notified when a promising property hits the market, even if its listed square footage is slightly below your target. That 1,900-square-foot home in your ideal Austin neighborhood might just have the perfect layout that “lives” larger than you’d expect. By expanding your search, you give yourself the opportunity to evaluate the home in person rather than dismissing it based on a potentially misleading number.
Considering Buying a Home in Austin?
Finding the right home is about more than just numbers; it’s about finding a space where your life can unfold beautifully. As experienced buyer’s agents with a combined 60+ years in the Austin market, we can help make your home search effective, worry-free, and even fun. We have proven strategies to help you find the perfect home and save you money—even in a competitive market.
Check out our Austin Home Buyer section to learn more about our buyer representation program. Then, when you’re ready, fill out our Buyer Survey or give us a call at (512) 827-8323 to schedule a no-obligation consultation. Let’s find you a home that feels right, regardless of what the square footage says.
Leave a Reply